Hidden Triple Technique: Finding Three Hidden Candidates
Hidden Triple is an advanced version of Hidden Pairs and a more complex intermediate Sudoku technique. The core idea is: when three candidates appear only in the same three cells of a unit (row, column, or box), those three cells must contain these three numbers, so you can eliminate all other candidates from these three cells.
If three candidates (such as 2, 4, 9) appear only in three specific cells within a row, column, or box, then these three numbers must occupy these three cells. Even if these cells have many other candidates, those other candidates must all be eliminated because these three cells can only contain those three "hidden" numbers.
Before reading this article, we recommend understanding Sudoku naming conventions and Hidden Pairs technique.
Example 1: Hidden Triple in a Row
Let's look at the first example, finding a hidden triple in Row 6.
Current Grid Data
Based on the CSV81 format candidate data, Row 6 looks like this:
- R6C1: Candidates {2, 4}
- R6C2: Filled with 5 (b5 means confirmed as 5)
- R6C3: Candidates {2, 4}
- R6C4: Candidates {3, 4, 9}
- R6C5: Candidates {6, 8}
- R6C6: Candidates {3, 6, 8}
- R6C7: Candidates {3, 7, 8}
- R6C8: Candidates {2, 3, 9}
- R6C9: Candidates {3, 6, 7}
Analysis Process
- Candidate 2 appears in: R6C1, R6C3, R6C8
- Candidate 4 appears in: R6C1, R6C3, R6C4
- Candidate 9 appears in: R6C4, R6C8
- R6C4: Eliminate candidate 3 (keep 4, 9)
- R6C8: Eliminate candidate 3 (keep 2, 9)
Hidden Triple: In Row 6, candidates 2, 4, 9 appear only in R6C3, R6C8, R6C4.
Action: Eliminate candidate 3 from R6C8, eliminate candidate 3 from R6C4.
Example 2: Hidden Triple in a Box
Now let's look at another example, finding a hidden triple in Box 6.
Current Grid Data
Based on the CSV81 format candidate data, Box 6 (Rows 4-6, Columns 7-9) looks like this:
- R4C7: Filled with 9 (b9 means confirmed as 9)
- R4C8: Candidates {1, 2, 7}
- R4C9: Candidates {1, 3, 7}
- R5C7: Filled with 6 (g6 means confirmed as 6)
- R5C8: Candidates {1, 2, 3, 7}
- R5C9: Filled with 9 (g9 means confirmed as 9)
- R6C7: Filled with 9 (b9 means confirmed as 9)
- R6C8: Candidates {3, 5}
- R6C9: Filled with 2 (g2 means confirmed as 2)
Analysis Process
- Candidate 1 appears in: R4C8, R4C9, R5C8
- Candidate 2 appears in: R4C8, R5C8
- Candidate 7 appears in: R4C8, R4C9, R5C8
- R4C9: Eliminate candidate 3 (keep 1, 7)
- R5C8: Eliminate candidate 3 (keep 1, 2, 7)
Hidden Triple: In Box 6, candidates 1, 2, 7 appear only in R4C8, R4C9, R5C8.
Action: Eliminate candidate 3 from R4C9, eliminate candidate 3 from R5C8.
Hidden Triple vs Hidden Pair
Let's compare Hidden Pairs and Hidden Triples:
| Comparison | Hidden Pair | Hidden Triple |
|---|---|---|
| Candidates involved | 2 candidates | 3 candidates |
| Cells involved | 2 cells | 3 cells |
| Recognition | Two numbers appear only in the same two cells | Three numbers appear only in the same three cells |
| Elimination target | Eliminate other candidates from these two cells | Eliminate other candidates from these three cells |
| Difficulty | Difficult | Very difficult |
| Frequency | Occasional | Rare |
Hidden Triples are harder to spot than Hidden Pairs because you need to track the distribution of three numbers within a unit, and this combination is often "masked" by many other candidates. For example, R5C8 has candidates {1,2,3,7}, containing the hidden triple numbers 1, 2, 7, but with 3 also present as "interference".
How to Find Hidden Triples
Finding Hidden Triples requires systematic and patient analysis:
- It must be three numbers appearing only in exactly the same three cells
- If numbers 1, 2 appear in R4C8, R4C9, R5C8, but number 7 appears in R4C8, R4C9, R5C8, R6C8, they don't form a hidden triple (number 7 has a wider distribution)
- The three numbers don't need to appear in every cell, e.g., R4C8 might have {1,2,7}, R4C9 might have {1,7}, R5C8 might have {1,2,7}
- Hidden Triples are very concealed and require careful, systematic analysis to discover
- Using candidate marking features makes tracking number distribution easier
Variations of Hidden Triples
Hidden Triples can appear in different forms:
- Complete type: Each cell contains some or all of the three numbers. Example: {1,2,7}, {1,2,7}, {1,2,7}
- Distributed type: The three numbers are distributed across the three cells. Example: {1,2}, {2,7}, {1,7}
- Mixed type: Some cells contain all three numbers, others only some. Example: {1,2,7}, {1,7}, {1,2,7}
Regardless of the form, the key is that these three numbers appear only in these three cells and not in other cells of that unit.
Technique Summary
Key points for applying Hidden Triple:
- Perspective: Observe from the number distribution angle, tracking where three numbers appear
- Recognition: Three candidates appear only in the same three cells within a unit
- Elimination target: Other candidates in these three cells
- Analysis method: Requires systematic, patient tracking of each candidate's distribution in the unit
- Difficulty: Harder to spot than Hidden Pairs, requires more careful observation
- Practical value: In complex difficult puzzles, can be the key technique to break through bottlenecks
Advanced: Comparison with Naked Triples
The counterpart to Hidden Triples is Naked Triples: When three cells in a unit have candidates that are all subsets of the same three numbers (like {1,2}, {2,7}, {1,7}), you can eliminate these three numbers from other cells in that unit.
Key difference:
- Naked Triple: Look at cell candidates, eliminate these three numbers from other cells
- Hidden Triple: Look at number distribution, eliminate other candidates from these three cells themselves
Start a Sudoku game and try using Hidden Triple to simplify complex candidates! Choose a row, column, or box with many candidates, systematically analyze each number's distribution, and see if you can find a hidden triple. We recommend mastering Hidden Pairs first before attempting to find Hidden Triples.